Sasa, This is only a concern for those who still harbour the illusion that Western Europe and America will be able to help the Arabs. That has never been and will never be the case. I’ve become incredibly pessimistic in recent years and am a firm believer that success and rejuvenation will be from within.
Wassim, I agree with you, and I think all Arabists would. We can’t depend on our colonial masters to help us.
But in an environment of conflict – where Israel and the US are preventing us developing, and providing an excuse to every leader in the region not to concentrate on domestic concerns. And at the same time, undermining opposition movements. How can we have faith in ourselves.
France’s future support for Israel will make our development as Arab nations, far less likely.
Sasa, firstly don’t you mean “former” colonial masters
Fair enough, we are not getting a break from anywhere, but in true Gramscian style, wouldn’t the foundations of a new superstructure be patiently constructed in the rotting foundations of the old corrupt one?
Liberation begins in the mind before the body. The more educated, mentally and morally strong individuals that emerge throughout our countries, the more weaker ones will gravitate to them. The power of example and the spoken word worked once before and can again for us. It just takes some self discipline IMHO
No, I left out the word ‘former’ for a reason. Who can call the American-Iraqi relationship or American-Gulf, or the Israeli-Palestinian, or the French-Lebanese, or many, many others, anything but colonialism.
Almost every Arab country has characteristics similar to those of locally-ruled colonies.
The foundations aren’t rotting – far from it. How can we rebuild, when the destruction continues?
And I don’t believe there is a battle for ideas as you suggest. The more educated, liberated the individual, the more they are bound to oppose the Arab world’s corrupt rule.
And the more they oppose authority, the more they are labelled traitors.
Ahh, good point on the Colonial label. I agree to that. I guess the situation is overall much more complex, but we both agree that more education is definitely the way forward.
However, what I fear is that we get an influx of Westernised Technocrats who would internalise big corporations and the Western elites’ dialogue and would perpetuate this neo-colonialism without the people even realising it. I guess what we are both trying to answer is your question, “How can we have faith in ourselves?”. I don’t have the answer to that, but I imagine that several attempts begin with sounding negative, but the one that succeeds is the one which thinks it can find an answer. The dearest thing we are missing is our self belief, without it, we’ll just keep sitting with “our hand on our cheek.”
I did some reasearch into Western vs developing world NGOs, and I fear the influx of norms and ideas from one part of the world has already happened. Some powerful NGOs are perpetuating the colonialism which I’m sure they are opposed to. So it is already happening.
I agree, we must have faith or we have nothing! And education is definately definately the way forward. It is our problem, and we have no one but ourselves to blame. It has to change, and it is a change of attitude, not money, that’s needed.
Leave a Comment
The Syria News Wire - fresh, independent news from the streets of Damascus and beyond.
Blogging Syria since 2005.
Contact
You can email me at:
mail at newsfromsyria dot com
As Syria’s rebel militias become more lethal, foreign analysts are trying to determine how Islamic they are, how to unify them, and what role the West can play in guiding Syria toward an outcome favorable to its interests. The Syrian government is exploiting Western concerns that the Syrian militias could turn out to be harmful […]
The Hamas-Syrian Split, a Dilemma for Iran’s Palestinian Strategy By Mohammad Ataie for Syria Comment May 13, 2012 Since the advent of the Iranian revolution, the Palestinian issue has been at the heart of the Islamic Republic’s foreign policy. For ideological and strategic reasons, supporting the Palestinian cause and resistance against Israel has been an [ […]
The main pillars of the Syrian regime are collapsing one after the other. The closing of the University of Aleppo signifies the beginning of the end for public education. It will only be the first of the universities to close. Most are trying to limp to the end of the academic year, but they will […]
A shaved version of this review appeared in the Guardian. In the 1980s an artist friend of mine made a poster for Gulbuddin Hekmatyar’s Hizb-e-Islami, a militia later allied with the Taliban. The poster depicted a fully-bearded Afghan mujahid clutching Quran and Kalashnikov and standing atop a slaughtered Russian bear. It was sent as a […]
A mangled version of this review appeared in the Independent. What is happening in the Middle East? Tariq Ramadan, one of the foremost Muslim intellectuals, calls the contemporary events ‘uprisings’, more concrete and permanent in their effect than ‘revolts’ but still short of thoroughgoing ‘revolutions’. So far, Tunisia is the only clear democratising succe […]
I haven’t been writing about Syria at my previous pace. The time is not right. This is a time for Syrian internet activists, those still surviving, to send us their videos. It’s a time for gathering evidence – although no more evidence is needed. It’s a time for reporters to write, for committed foreign journalists […]
I got an email about a planned march in support of proportional representation (PR), which will take place in Beirut on May 13. In a way, conditions are ripe these days for Lebanese civil society groups to push their agenda for electoral reform because: (a) the issue is front and center again, and (b) because […]
I have finished the dissertation that I’ve been writing and which has lately kept me from blogging more often Forgive me It was onerous So long And so dense […]
As it so happens, there are other things one can do with a camera phone during a revolution besides filming gun battles. I recently arrived late to a very good party, the party of Jiim Siin’s brilliant and wickedly satirical monologues about the Syrian uprising. Recorded on an iPhone by an anonymous Syrian fellow living […]
6 responses so far ↓
1 Wassim // May 20, 2007 at 5.21 pm
Sasa,
This is only a concern for those who still harbour the illusion that Western Europe and America will be able to help the Arabs. That has never been and will never be the case. I’ve become incredibly pessimistic in recent years and am a firm believer that success and rejuvenation will be from within.
2 sasa // May 20, 2007 at 5.24 pm
Wassim, I agree with you, and I think all Arabists would. We can’t depend on our colonial masters to help us.
But in an environment of conflict – where Israel and the US are preventing us developing, and providing an excuse to every leader in the region not to concentrate on domestic concerns. And at the same time, undermining opposition movements. How can we have faith in ourselves.
France’s future support for Israel will make our development as Arab nations, far less likely.
S.
3 Wassim // May 20, 2007 at 5.33 pm
Sasa, firstly don’t you mean “former” colonial masters
Fair enough, we are not getting a break from anywhere, but in true Gramscian style, wouldn’t the foundations of a new superstructure be patiently constructed in the rotting foundations of the old corrupt one?
Liberation begins in the mind before the body. The more educated, mentally and morally strong individuals that emerge throughout our countries, the more weaker ones will gravitate to them. The power of example and the spoken word worked once before and can again for us. It just takes some self discipline IMHO
4 sasa // May 20, 2007 at 5.39 pm
No, I left out the word ‘former’ for a reason. Who can call the American-Iraqi relationship or American-Gulf, or the Israeli-Palestinian, or the French-Lebanese, or many, many others, anything but colonialism.
Almost every Arab country has characteristics similar to those of locally-ruled colonies.
The foundations aren’t rotting – far from it. How can we rebuild, when the destruction continues?
And I don’t believe there is a battle for ideas as you suggest. The more educated, liberated the individual, the more they are bound to oppose the Arab world’s corrupt rule.
And the more they oppose authority, the more they are labelled traitors.
5 Wassim // May 20, 2007 at 6.06 pm
Ahh, good point on the Colonial label. I agree to that. I guess the situation is overall much more complex, but we both agree that more education is definitely the way forward.
However, what I fear is that we get an influx of Westernised Technocrats who would internalise big corporations and the Western elites’ dialogue and would perpetuate this neo-colonialism without the people even realising it. I guess what we are both trying to answer is your question, “How can we have faith in ourselves?”. I don’t have the answer to that, but I imagine that several attempts begin with sounding negative, but the one that succeeds is the one which thinks it can find an answer. The dearest thing we are missing is our self belief, without it, we’ll just keep sitting with “our hand on our cheek.”
6 sasa // May 20, 2007 at 6.10 pm
Wassim,
I did some reasearch into Western vs developing world NGOs, and I fear the influx of norms and ideas from one part of the world has already happened. Some powerful NGOs are perpetuating the colonialism which I’m sure they are opposed to. So it is already happening.
I agree, we must have faith or we have nothing! And education is definately definately the way forward. It is our problem, and we have no one but ourselves to blame. It has to change, and it is a change of attitude, not money, that’s needed.
Leave a Comment