Syria News Wire

Syria News Wire header image 2

Syria: the bad old good old days

August 21st, 2012 · 7 Comments · Politics

An interesting argument is brewing over on The Spectator blog, between Nick Cohen and the always readable Matthew Teller.

It started off as a rant against travel guidebooks, Lonely Planet in particular. But it has ended up in a fight over who knew what, and when, about Assad.

Cohen’s opening salvo pulls out a few lines from the (2004?) Lonely Planet guide to Syria, as if to mock with his crystal clear hindsight:

Assad’s pre-revolutionary Syria, the guide informs readers, was a land with cautious hope for the future. ‘Reforms by the young president of Syria, Bashar al-Assad, may not have been as wide-ranging as many might have hoped, but there is certainly a feeling of optimism in the capital. Culture and tourism are high on the agenda and Damascus has responded with a flurry of art gallery and hotel openings (including the long-awaited Four Seasons).’

The thing is, the book is absolutely right. There was cautious hope in Damascus, the regime was pushing culture and tourism hard (the Arab Capital of Culture was a massive deal for the regime), and expat Syrians were returning to the country.

Elsewhere in the book, the Hama massacre, political prisoners, and the death of the Damascus Spring are all detailed. Cohen’s selective reading fails to pick up on this.

Matthew Teller, never a fan of Assad, picks up the argument:

Perhaps Cohen doesn’t know much about the Middle East, but there really were, on all sides, high hopes for Syria in the few years after Bashar al-Assad’s rise to power: indeed, the Western media dubbed the period the “Damascus Spring”. I can personally vouch for the accuracy of Lonely Planet’s identification of “a feeling of optimism in the capital” around that time. It’s easy to imply, as Cohen does, that writing about gallery openings and new hotels is a pernicious insult when placed beside the murderous violence we are now witnessing, but then hindsight has always been a seductive tool. At the time, in 2006, Syria-watchers were well aware that the opening of the Four Seasons in Damascus signalled the possibility of improving economic liberalisation. By 2009 even The Economist – notorious, of course, for its lefty whitewashing – was noting that “reforms have tapped suppressed entrepreneurial vigour [in Syria]”. Then the wheels came off, with unspeakably awful consequences. Journalists were wrong about Syria. Academics were wrong. Diplomats were wrong. Syrians themselves were wrong. But Cohen thinks the author of the Lonely Planet should have got it right.

Cohen can’t let it go. His argument is hollow, and he doesn’t seem to understand that a paragraph he copies and pastes from the Lonely Planet website about Syria coming in from the cold is probably years old.

The fact is this – the revolution took us all by surprise, even lifelong anti-Assad activists. Cohen, though, saw it all coming. Shame he didn’t tell us back then.

If you’re struggling to remember what the world thought of Syria pre-March 2011, have a look at this compilation of Syria stories by Jillian York.

 

Tags:

7 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Papou // Aug 22, 2012 at 5.38 pm

    That what’s we needed; a story from an israeli to evaluate Syria…This is the last joke ever

  • 2 peter // Aug 22, 2012 at 5.53 pm

    Cohen was hung in Syria over 30 years ago for spying

  • 3 Jillian // Aug 23, 2012 at 11.39 pm

    Thanks for the shoutout; Cohen’s argument is, frankly, stupid. Sure, the “you have to hand it to Assad junior” line is cheesy, but so is just about every LP (the Moroccan one is by far the worst, going so far as to present the king as an entirely benevolent monarch loved by all, ahem).

  • 4 A tourism revolution « Quite Alone // Feb 6, 2013 at 5.32 pm

    [...] is not to condemn anybody in travel for complicity with dictatorship, passive or otherwise. None of us foresaw the uprisings. Nobody did – not journalists, not analysts, not the people [...]

  • 5 We Cannot Remain Ignorant And Biased About Syria (Lessons For Brainwashed Minds) « The Northernmost Gamma // Feb 17, 2013 at 8.01 am

    [...] Prior to the arab spring Assad himself was not generally seen as a particularly brutal dictator. A Lonely Planet travel guide…: [...]

  • 6 prix sac louis vuitton // Aug 11, 2014 at 9.12 am

    l. a,chicago FIFA réfléchit à l’augmentation du nombre l’ordre de locations participantes qui passerait 16 à 24, Ceci flood répondre à los angeles popunflrité croissante du environnant les féminin et Coupe du Mon féminine. Cette proposal delaware Sepp Blatter, the présil’ordre dent los angeles Fédération Internationa, N’en se ‘vrrle rrtre seulement qu’au stapour l. a,chicago article. durante effet los angeles victoire écrasante l’o

  • 7 air max noir // Aug 27, 2014 at 9.14 am

    Mais within s’en fout, C’est the open to the public qui any kind of dernier mot. los angeles cultivation air max fille l’ordre de l’ission, si ils veulent continuer l’ison, Devraient reprendre air max pas cher l. a,chicago copie?Zo et peut lso are i am thecrr air max noir imagined, Changer l. a,chicago saison environnant les diffusion, Faire united nations spreading parfait, Faire ce nike bw qu’united nationse ission n’a jamais fait air max safari et tout faire plastic bottles redonner second so

Leave a Comment